So while getting my transmission to stop leaking, I discovered another issue while under my car. My lower bolt that mounts my starter to the transmission bell housing (C4 automatic) was hanging out 1/2 way and not even tight. Now for some back story, I had everything put together nicely on this when I dropped it off at a mechanic to finish my car years ago and just got my car back, with a lot of issues and other problems that get my blood boiling (story for another time). Needless to say...

Starter Bolt Problems